Listed by Torri Bendel · Brokered by Mountain Retreat Realty Experts, LLC - Lakeside

1 of 44

● For sale

$442,999

Est. $2,729/mo

2880 Paint Pony Lane, Overgaard, AZ 85933

Holiday Forest Sub · Navajo County

4 beds 3 baths 2,323 sqft 0.28 acres Built 1984 $191 /sqft No HOA

264 days on market | 211 views | 5 saves

What's special

No HOA
Fireplace

Description

Bring all reasonable offers, motivated seller! Escape to the cool mountain air in this beautifully maintained 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath cabin nestled among the tall pines of Overgaard. This spacious two-story home offers the perfect blend of rustic charm and modern comfort, making it an ideal full-time residence, vacation getaway, or short-term rental. Step inside to find a welcoming living area featuring a cozy wood stove and plenty of natural light. The well designed layout includes a convenient mud room, a fully furnished interior, and a kitchen ready for all your culinary adventures. Upstairs, the huge master suite is a true retreat with its private balcony overlooking the serene forest views. Enjoy the fresh mountain breeze from the front patio or entertain guests on the backyard deck. A large storage shed provides ample room for tools, gear, or hobbies, while the metal roof ensures lasting durability. Also, no HOA! An added bonus! This property includes the adjoining lot, giving you extra space for all your toys, RV, or potential future expansion. All fully fenced with 20 foot sliding gates! Don't miss this opportunity to own your slice of mountain paradise in Overgaard! Move-in ready, fully furnished and ready for your new memories! No HOA!

Listing updated: August 19, 2026

Listed by:

Torri Bendel torri‌@‌mtnretreatrealty.com, Mountain Retreat Realty Experts, LLC - Lakeside

Source: White Mountain Association of REALTORS®, MLS#: 259624

See this home in person

Teri & Jenny will show you this home, answer your questions, and help you through the buying process.

Next available tour: Tomorrow

Interested in buying?

Make a strong offer with help from Teri & Jenny.

Property details

Interior

Bedrooms

Bedrooms: 4

Bathrooms

Total Bathrooms: 3

Interior Features

Kitchen/Dining Room Combo
Window Features: Bay Window(s), Blinds, Double Pane Windows, Screens, Skylight(s), Window Coverings

Appliances

Refrigerator
Dishwasher
Disposal
Electric Range
Microwave

Heating and Cooling

Heating Features: Propane, Forced Air
Fireplace: Yes
Fireplace Features: Living Room

Other Interior

Levels: Two

Exterior

Exterior and Lot Features

Patio and Porch Features: Covered Patio, Deck, Front Porch, Porch
Fencing: Private

Land Info

Lot Size Acres: 0.28
Lot Size Square Feet: 12,196.8

Community

Homeowners Association

Association: No

Neighborhood

Subdivision: Holiday Forest Sub
MLS Area: Overgaard

Listing

Other Property Info

Annual Tax Amount: $1,716
Source Listing Status: Active
County: Navajo
Directions: From Show Low, take the highway 260 West to Heber. Turn left at Lumber Valley Rd, right on Long Rifle Pl, left on Wilderness Dr, right on Paint Pony Ln, house on the left.
Property Subtype: Site Built
Parcel Number: 206-24-156A
Postal City: Overgaard
Listing Date: 2/20/2026
On Market Date: 2/20/2026
MLS#: 259624

Features

Building and Construction

Total Square Feet Living: 2,323
Year Built: 1984
Property Age: 42
Architectural Style: 2nd Level
Roof: Metal
Foundation Details: Other
Levels: Two
Living Area Source: Appraiser

Utilities

Sewer: Septic Tank

Monthly payment

$2,729/month

Principal and interest $2,401
Property taxes from the listing $143
Home insurance estimated $185

Home price $ Down payment % · $88,600 Loan term Interest rate % Home insurance $/mo

An estimate only, not a loan offer or rate quote. Starting rates are Freddie Mac's weekly national averages (Nov 5, 2026) and aren't an APR. Your rate and costs depend on your credit and lender. Property taxes often change after a sale, and insurance varies by home, especially in wildfire areas.

Price history

Date	Event	Price	$/sqft
Jul 3, 2026	Price decreased Source: WMAR #259624	$442,999 -$37,001 (-7.7%)	$191/sqft
Feb 19, 2026	Listed for sale Source: WMAR #259624	$480,000	$207/sqft

Talk to a local expert

Teri Meacham

REALTOR® with West USA Realty · 25+ years in the High Country · 500+ homes sold

Tour this home or ask anything about it
Get what the listing doesn't say: water, septic, road access, HOA rules
See recent sales nearby before you make an offer

Data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange (IDX) program of White Mountain Association of REALTORS®. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use, and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. The data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS.

All information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed accurate by the White Mountain Association of REALTORS®